How to Choose a Reputable Maine Coon Breeder in Florida
Red Flags to Watch for When Buying a Maine Coon Kitten
[How to Choose a Reputable Breeder]
Time and time again, I hear horror stories from individuals and families who were scammed or ended up with a sub par kitten. As a breeder, that genuinely saddens me, not just because of the financial loss, but because it often becomes their first and only experience with a Maine Coon breeder.
By the time many of these families reach out to me, they are hesitant, guarded, and disappointed. I jokingly say I become a bit of a cat therapist, and honestly, I do not mind at all. Rebuilding trust is part of what I do. Ethical breeders truly care about both the cats we steward and the families we place them with.
So let’s get into the nitty gritty.
Below are the most common red flags I see when buyers are searching for a Maine Coon kitten, and how to protect yourself from heartbreak.
Red Flag #1: “Bargain” Maine Coon Kittens
Buying a Maine Coon is not the time to hunt for a bargain.
I can say with a lot of confidence that any kitten priced under $2,000 is very likely:
A scam
Unhealthy
Not a Maine Coon at all
That said, it can swing the other way.
If someone is charging far above typical market rates, that is also something to question. Unless you plan to show cats professionally, there is usually no need to pay an inflated premium based purely on hyped bloodlines, especially if you are a first time Maine Coon owner and unlikely to know any of them.
“European Maine Coons”
Here is the truth.
Most Maine Coons in the United States already have European bloodlines. And can anyone guess where Maine Coons originated from? That’s right Maine Coons originated in the great state of Maine. So there is an argument to be made on the “European Maine Coon” that I will leave for another time.
So when you see extremely high prices justified only by vague claims like “European lines,” ask directly: Why are your prices significantly higher than other reputable breeders?
A good breeder will gladly explain.If the answer is just buzzwords, and over edited glam pictures I would move right along.
Red Flag #2: Overseas Sellers
Even as a breeder, I am extremely cautious about importing cats. I have only done so through breeders personally recommended by people I trust. If a seller overseas contacts you unsolicited or pressures you into a quick decision, that is a major red flag. International transactions add complexity, risk, and very limited recourse if something goes wrong.
Red Flag #3: No Videos or Live Interaction
A reputable breeder should be willing to:
Share multiple photos
Talk over the phone
Send updated videos
Do a live video call
If they avoid real time interaction or recycle the same few photos, be cautious.
Red Flag #4: Excessive Pressure or Urgency
Yes, Maine Coon kittens can go quickly. I am always honest about that with my pet parents and I run a first come first served philosophy. Unless you are on our paid waitlist. But over the top urgency, pressure tactics, or guilt based selling are not normal. Ethical breeders want you to feel confident, not rushed.
Red Flag #5: Unclear Location or Shipping Details
Be wary if a breeder:
Will not allow in person pickup or explain delivery clearly
Refuses to share their general location
Is vague about how kittens are transported or wants to use a courrier that isn’t easily researched.
Transparency matters, especially when a living animal is involved.
Red Flag #6: Suspicious Communication
Poor grammar alone is not always a dealbreaker, but broken English paired with evasive answers, inconsistent details, or strange and repeated payment requests is absolutely a red flag.
Trust your instincts here.
Red Flag #7: No Online Presence or Reviews
Everyone starts somewhere, but proceed carefully if:
Social media accounts were created very recently
Photos look inconsistent or lifted from other sites
There are no reviews, testimonials, or references
Reputable breeders leave a trail. Happy families talk. Now, there may be rare situations where one of these red flags has a reasonable explanation. That said, you ideally want to avoid all of the red flags listed above, and if you encounter multiple red flags at once, that is your sign to absolutely run for the hills.
Health Testing: What You Should Ask Every Breeder
One of the best ways to vet a Maine Coon breeder is by asking about health testing.
At an absolute minimum:
Breeding cats should have DNA testing
Cats should receive routine veterinary care
Annual vaccinations should be up to date
These are simple questions, and a good breeder will be happy to answer them.
Contracts Matter
Let me say it clearly.Contracts! Contracts! Contracts!
Your kitten should always come with a contract outlining:
Price and deposits
Health guarantees
Spay and neuter timelines
Buyer and breeder responsibilities
Please read it all the way through.Here at Singularity Maine Coons, our contract is detailed. I am happy to explain it, but I cannot read it for you. Staying informed protects everyone involved.
Transparency Is the Final Test
Any breeder worth their salt will happily talk your ear off about:
Their cats
Their breeding practices
Their health protocols
Their philosophy
When someone says, “I hope you do not mind me asking,” my response is usually:“How much time do you have?” Because I could talk about this for hours. If a breeder seems guarded, defensive, or unwilling to share, that is not a great sign.
Final Thoughts
Buying a Maine Coon kitten should be an exciting and positive experience, not a stressful one.
As a breeder, my goal is simple:
Protect the cats
Educate buyers
Build lifelong trust
If something feels off, pause and ask questions. A reputable breeder will never fault you for doing your homework. You should feel good and happy when buying your kitten not feeling lost.
Ready to Learn More?
Apply for a kitten
View Pricing
Contact Singularity Maine Coons